Image copyright laws Ellie Harrison Image caption musician Ellie Harrison and also the image she's regularly publicise the woman Glasgow Effect project
Arts body Creative Scotland features defended giving a musician £15, 000 to invest annually without leaving Glasgow.
Ellie Harrison's project is called the Glasgow impact - a term regarding poor health in parts of the town.
The artist stated she desired to explore durability by traveling less and concentrating more about neighborhood options.
Experts on social networking have explained it as a waste of cash but imaginative Scotland said Harrison's powerful suggestion had skilled for capital.
On an internet page outlining the task, Harrison says: "The Glasgow impact is year-long action research project / durational performance, for which musician Ellie Harrison won't travel outside Greater Glasgow for a whole year (except in the eventuality of the ill-heath / loss of close general or friend).
"By setting this 1 quick constraint to her present life style, she intends to test the limits of a 'sustainable rehearse' and to challenge the demand-to-travel placed upon the 'successful' singer / educational."
Although some reaction on Twitter and Facebook to the task was good, other people described it as patronising and a waste of money.
Kieran Hurley tweeted: "All I know about #TheGlasgowEffect is there was an ill-judged press release by a musician who has got previously done good work. That's it."
Michael Gray tweeted: "each and every time some one tweets me personally about #TheGlasgowEffect, a @CreativeScots manager adds it to their tally of 'met crucial overall performance signs'."
'Patronises and insults'
On Facebook, Alex William McRobbie, posted: "The financing of these a project both patronises and insults the poorest living inside the town of Glasgow.
"I'm sure of several young musicians that haven't left the city before 12 months due to monetary pressures."
Amanda Cameron stated: "why-not enter and all over town and inquire people who actually do stay, work and have created a presence on their own - perhaps not inside name of art, but because their real lives?!
"It is a complete waste of money... and a punch in the face to people residing and working in Glasgow!"
Harrison later on published on Twitter that she was in negotiations with Duncan of Jordanstone university, where she lectures in contemporary art, "to give the £15, 000 in their mind in exchange for paid analysis leave to be able to undertake the task".
Referring to response on social networking, she stated: "Glasgow is my home for seven-and-a-half many years and to instantly have actually a reply similar to this to one of my jobs was quite overwhelming.
"You have provided myself a great deal product to absorb, it will require the entire year to do this. I really hope to follow-up by fulfilling several of you face-to-face, when most of the hassle has actually died down."
The singer also promised to "briefly submit" her complete application to innovative Scotland "in the interests of transparency and also to offer a more detail by detail context for project".
She ended the post: "At least today, as a result of you all, i've ticked the innovative Scotland's 'Public Engagement' package, I can log on to with all the real work."
Innovative Scotland defended its decision to provide financing.
In a statement, the arts human anatomy stated Harrison was "a recognised singer with an MA with Distinction through the Glasgow class of Art".
The statement proceeded: "the woman idea, articulated in a powerful suggestion which met all criteria for open task financing, dedicated to checking out be it feasible for an artist to generate an existence for themselves by living, working and leading to a single neighborhood, as opposed to being constantly on the way due to the must earn money from commissions from different locations where incur expensive travel and accommodation expenses and high carbon impact consumption.
"Ellie's task is dependent on the premise that if society desires to attain international modification, then people have to be more energetic inside their communities at a nearby degree.
"In limiting herself to remaining inside the city boundaries she's keen to explore just what influence this can have the girl on her behalf life as well as on her work as an artist with nationwide and worldwide commitments."
The statement concluded: "Our capital will support Ellie's imaginative practice in Glasgow and we will be interested to see how the task advances.